The NHS Priorities/CAMEOL Project

Executive Summary


Background
This project involved the appraisal and review of the research evidence on complementary therapies in the NHS priority areas as defined by Government policy prior to the start of the project. These areas were: cancer, mental health, heart disease and stroke, and chronic conditions (arthritis, asthma, chronic back pain, diabetes, multiple sclerosis). The therapies included in the project were acupuncture, Alexander technique, aromatherapy, chiropractic, homeopathy, herbal medicine (specific products), hypnotherapy, massage, meditation, osteopathy, reflexology and yoga.

Aims
• To carry out a detailed review and critical appraisal of the published research on specific complementary therapies
• To make this information available to health care professionals, researchers and the public via the Internet
• To maintain an evidence-based information resource that reflects current research evidence

Project organisation
The main project team consisted of a project director, project manager, two research assistants and an information specialist. An advisory group consisting of representatives from the National Library for Health, Cochrane Collaboration, NHS Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, a complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) organisation and a patient organisation provided advice on overall strategy and methods. Clinicians and therapists were recruited to provide condition and therapy specific advice and to comment on the clinical relevance of studies. External experts were consulted on specific aspects of the topics and to provide overall comments on each review.

Methods
The scale and complexity of the project required a range of processes and methods to be developed and tested. The methods used for each of the reviews involved comprehensive searches of electronic databases which were followed by the filtering and categorising of articles according to the study design. Basic methodology of relevant articles was appraised, and commentaries provided by clinical specialists. Reviews were sent for external comment and then either submitted for publication in peer-reviewed journals with a summary on the CAMEOL (Complementary and Alternative Medicine Evidence OnLine) database, or published in full on CAMEOL. The later stages of the project required planning for the integration of the methods and outcomes of the work into the newly established National Library for Health (NLH) CAM Specialist Library (www.library.nhs.uk/cam)

Outcomes
This project succeeded in bringing together a wide range of research literature on complementary therapies in chronic and life-threatening illnesses in a short space of time. The main outcome was a new resource, the CAMEOL database, providing access to summaries and full details of the research on each topic including unpublished and ongoing studies, tables of studies incorporating methodological appraisals and clinical comments, and links to relevant evidence. Supplementary outcomes included: a review of currently available electronic sources of CAM information, development of search strategies for a range of CAM therapies, investigations into the contribution of non-English language and qualitative research and into the quality of reporting of CAM interventions in research studies. Furthermore, the project established a framework and system for ensuring that evidence-based knowledge of CAM can be available to both professionals and the public.

An evaluation of the search methods has been conducted and the results published. The overall methods for the cancer reviews have also been evaluated in collaboration with the Penny Brohn Cancer Centre and the resulting recommendations incorporated into development of a cancer-specific information service. Knowledge generated by the project has been shared with/transferred to other organisations including the CRD and Cochrane Collaboration.

The majority of the work has been or will be integrated in the near future into the NLH CAM Specialist Library by means of National Knowledge Weeks (NKW) and Annual Evidence Updates (AEU). These are initiatives carried out by the Specialist Libraries aimed at highlighting the ‘best current evidence for selected healthcare topics’ (www.library.nhs.uk/specialistlibraries/). The work on cancer is being progressed through a project by the University of Plymouth in collaboration with the Penny Brohn Cancer Centre while it is anticipated that work on the other major area, mental health, will continue at the University of Westminster. The supplementary study on qualitative research will continue as part of a project led by colleagues at the Peninsula College of Medicine and Dentistry School (Universities of Exeter and Plymouth).

Summary of the outputs
• 12 systematic reviews and overviews published in journals and 27 systematic reviews and overviews published on CAMEOL
• 13 reviews of reviews transferred to the NLH CAM Specialist Library
• 3 published papers relating to the methods
• 3 published papers on the overall project
• Ongoing projects based on the work on cancer, mental health and qualitative research in CAM
• Collaborative information-based projects (an international collaboration, an initiative to establish a European CAM information centre, development of the NLH CAM Specialist Library)

Page last updated: 26th March 2008

Research Council for Complementary Medicine, The Royal London Homoeopathic Hospital,
UCLH NHS Foundation Trust, 60 Great Ormond Street, London, WC1 3HR
Email: info@rccm.org.uk Website: www.rccm.org.uk